ECB: Interconnected Financial Sectors Create "Robust-Yet-Fragile" Liquidity Risks
SDG 9: Industry, Innovation and Infrastructure | SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals
Reserve Bank of India | Ministry of Finance
The European Central Bank (ECB) working paper titled ‘Liquidity spirals’ introduces a scenario-free method to identify liquidity spirals by analyzing the interactions between multiple contagion channels and institutional sectors.
The paper highlights the risks posed by liquidity spirals—self-reinforcing declines in market and funding liquidity—on financial stability, as evidenced during the 2007-2008 financial crisis.
The research demonstrates that financial stability is not merely a product of individual institutional strength but is fundamentally shaped by the Solvency-Liquidity Nexus and the collective response of banks and Non-Bank Financial Institutions (NBFIs) to shocks. By utilizing a shock transmission matrix, regulators can now detect emerging spirals before market liquidity collapses or funding markets lock up.
A critical finding of the study is the role of pecking orders—the sequence in which institutions liquidate assets—in creating “robust-yet-fragile” systems. Institutions that prioritize selling their most liquid assets first (the optimistic pecking order) remain resilient to frequent small shocks but become exceptionally vulnerable when a large shock exhausts those buffers, forcing the sale of illiquid assets and intensifying the spiral. Applied to the South African financial system, the model identified that spirals can be driven by a single sector’s instability or, more often, by the combined dynamics of interconnected banks and investment funds.
What is the ‘Solvency-Liquidity Nexus’ in systemic risk? It refers to the self-reinforcing relationship between an institution’s ability to meet long-term obligations (solvency) and its immediate capacity to generate cash (liquidity). In a crisis, a liquidity shock can force a solvent institution to sell assets at fire-sale prices, which depresses the value of those assets for the entire market. These mark-to-market losses can then erode the institution’s capital, turning a temporary liquidity problem into a fatal solvency crisis that triggers further contagion across the financial system.
What is a ‘Liquidity Spiral’ in the context of financial contagion? It is a self-reinforcing feedback loop where a decline in market and funding liquidity triggers further declines, progressively worsening the overall stability of the financial system. This process often begins when an institution, hit by an initial shock, is forced to sell assets to raise cash. These “fire sales” depress market prices, leading to valuation losses for other institutions holding similar assets. These losses can then trigger additional rounds of asset liquidations or funding withdrawals, creating a “snowball effect” that continues until the system either stabilizes or collapses into a full-blown liquidity crisis.
Policy Relevance
The framework provides a strategic tool for central banks to design targeted interventions, shifting away from broad liquidity injections toward sector-specific support that addresses the root of a spiral.
Strategic Impact for India:
NBFI-Bank Interconnectedness: The study warns that ignoring the interplay between the banking sector and NBFIs (like mutual funds) can lead to a severe underestimation of systemic risk during periods of market stress.
Targeted Central Bank Support: Analysis shows that central bank liquidity injections are only effective if they target the specific sector driving the spiral; simply funding banks may not stabilize the system if NBFIs are the primary source of instability.
Liquidation Strategy Oversight: Regulators can use this model to monitor institutional liquidation strategies, identifying when a “robust-yet-fragile” configuration poses a threat to national financial stability.
Scenario-Free Stress Testing: Moving beyond subjective stress scenarios to an eigenvalue-based stability measure allows for a more comprehensive assessment of resilience across a broad spectrum of unexpected shocks.
Follow the full news here: Liquidity spirals