SDG 16: Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions | SDG 17: Partnerships for the Goals
Ministry of Finance (MoF) | Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
The ECB Working Paper (No. 3175) titled ‘Understanding the inflation–output relationship across business cycle phases’ investigates the state-dependent nature of monetary policy transmission, revealing how the effectiveness of central bank actions varies across different phases of the business cycle. By analyzing four distinct economic regimes—inflationary boom, disinflationary boom, inflationary slack, and disinflationary slack—the study uncovers significant asymmetries in the slopes of the Phillips and Dynamic Investment-Savings (DIS) curves, as well as the Federal Reserve’s policy responses. Key findings indicate that while the Taylor principle holds consistently across all regimes to ensure economic stability, the sensitivity of the macroeconomy to interest rate changes declines sharply during periods of inflationary slack.
Regime-Specific Economic Asymmetries
Phillips Curve Dynamics: The Phillips curve steepens significantly during inflationary booms (inflation > target, output > potential), meaning demand and monetary shocks have much more pronounced effects on inflation in this state.
DIS Curve Sensitivity: The sensitivity of the output gap to interest rates is flatter when inflation is above target and output is below potential (inflationary slack), making policy changes less effective at stimulating the economy.
Policy Response Variation: Federal Reserve responses to the output gap weaken when inflation is below target but output remains above potential, whereas reactions to inflation remain broadly similar across states.
Monetary Shock Size: The magnitude of monetary policy shocks is significantly larger when inflation exceeds its target, reflecting the central bank’s heightened focus on controlling high inflation.
Data Dependence: The study finds that the Federal Reserve exhibits higher data dependence during periods of inflationary slack, prioritizing recent indicators over forward-looking models to avoid destabilizing errors.
Strategic Impact for Global Policymakers
Limitations of Linear Models: Traditional linear models that assume constant relationships between variables are insufficient for capturing the heterogeneity of the real-world economy.
Optimal Policy Design: Identifying the prevailing economic regime is central to designing optimal monetary policy, as restrictive actions are most effective during inflationary booms.
Inflation Determination: The steepening of the Phillips curve during booms might imply a stronger determination by central banks to fight inflation when resource constraints are high.
What is ‘State Dependence’ in monetary policy and why is it critical for central bank effectiveness? It refers to the phenomenon where the impact of central bank actions—such as interest rate adjustments—depends on the prevailing economic state, specifically the levels of inflation and resource utilization. This is critical because the structural relationships governing the economy, such as the Phillips curve, are not constant. For example, the study finds that transmission becomes less effective when elevated inflation coincides with economic slack. Recognising these shifts allows policymakers to tailor their responses, using more aggressive measures during inflationary booms when the economy is highly sensitive, while exercising caution during slack periods where the impact of rate changes is muted.
Policy Relevance
The findings provide a nuanced framework for central banks to navigate complex economic dilemmas, particularly when balancing growth and price stability.
Tailoring RBI Responses: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) can leverage state-dependent insights to refine its Inflation Targeting framework, recognizing that the “sacrifice ratio” for reducing inflation changes with the output gap.
Managing Supply Shocks: Understanding that the Phillips curve steepens under resource constraints helps India manage volatile food and energy prices, ensuring that monetary contraction is used most effectively during growth spurts.
Infrastructure for Data-Driven Policy: Increased data dependence during inflationary slack underscores the need for real-time, high-frequency economic indicators to prevent “policy errors” in sensitive environments.
Calibrating Interest Rate Cycles: Recognising that consumers cut spending more drastically when inflation is below target helps India time its rate cuts to maximise their impact on private consumption.
Follow the full news here: Understanding the inflation–output relationship across business cycle phases