UNU Report Flags India's Digital Paradox: High Digital Maturity (GDI) Fails to Align with Expected Human Development (HDI) and Wellbeing Outcomes
SDG 9: Industry, Innovation and Infrastructure | SDG 10: Reduced Inequalities
Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) | NITI Aayog | Ministry of Finance
The white paper from the United Nations University, titled Digital Maturity and Sustainability - Unpacking the Interrelationships between the Global Digitalization Index and Human Development, analyzes the nexus between national digital maturity, measured by the Global Digitalization Index (GDI), and sustainable development indicators (SDIs). The GDI, an index comprised of four pillars—Ubiquitous Connectivity (UC), Digital Foundation (DF), Green Energy (GE), and Policy & Ecosystem (P&E)—is found to have a very strong positive correlation (ρ ≥ 0.8) with aggregate indicators of human development, wellbeing, and governance, including the Human Development Index (HDI), Rule of Law, and Social Progress Index (SPI) - Wellbeing.
The GDI classifies nations into three categories based on their digital maturity: Frontrunners, Adopters, and Starters. India is categorized as a digital Adopter, meaning the country is rapidly progressing in digital development
Strong Correlation: The strong link between the GDI and HDIs suggests that digital development is closely tied to national investments in social development.
Weak Correlation: The GDI shows weaker connections with measures of inclusivity (Gender Gap), political participation, peace, and environmental quality (Air Quality, ρ=0.42). These weak associations represent structural factors that evolve over longer periods.
Pillar Analysis: The Policy & Ecosystem (P&E) pillar shows the highest interrelations with soft governance indicators like inclusivity (ρ=0.52) and Voice and Accountability (ρ=0.65), suggesting robust digital strategies and supportive regulatory frameworks are crucial for non-technical social progress. The Green Energy (GE) pillar showed the weakest links overall, reflecting that investment in sustainable energy for digital infrastructure has yet to catch up with other development facets globally.
India-Specific Details
India is categorized as a digital Adopter in the GDI clusters, indicating a country that is rapidly progressing in digital development.
HDI/Wellbeing Outlier: India displays an outlier pattern when comparing its digital maturity to its human development outcomes. The analysis notes that India has relatively high levels of digital maturity (GDI) but low levels of HDI compared to other Adopter countries (.
Wellbeing Deficit: Similarly, when plotted against the SPI - Wellbeing (a non-economic measure of education, health, and environment), India shows lower levels of Wellbeing than would be expected based on its digital maturity score.
Cybersecurity Stance: Despite its classification as an Adopter, India is grouped with countries demonstrating Role-modelling cybersecurity practices (the highest Global Cybersecurity Index tier).
Policy Relevance
India’s status as an Adopter with high GDI but low HDI/Wellbeing suggests a significant policy challenge: the country has successfully built robust digital infrastructure and connectivity (Enablers), but the benefits are not yet fully translating into broad, inclusive social outcomes (SDGs/Wellbeing). Closing this translation gap requires targeted policy action on the softer pillars, particularly improving inclusivity (Gender Gap) and environmental outcomes (Air Quality), where the overall GDI correlation remains weakest.
What is the Global Digitalization Index (GDI)? The GDI is a comprehensive metric, developed by Huawei and IDC, that measures a country’s digital maturity across four pillars: Ubiquitous Connectivity (network coverage), Digital Foundation (cloud, AI, IoT adoption), Green Energy (sustainability investments), and Policy & Ecosystem (strategy, governance). It is used to categorize countries into Frontrunners, Adopters, and Starters.
What is the Human Development Index (HDI)? The Human Development Index (HDI) is a composite measure, created by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), used to evaluate and rank countries based on social and economic development, extending beyond solely economic wealth. It assesses three essential aspects of human development: a long and healthy life, access to knowledge, and a decent standard of living, producing a score between 0 and 1.
What is the Social Progress Index (SPI) ? The Social Progress Index (SPI) is a comprehensive measure of a country’s social and environmental outcomes, assessing societal well-being independently of economic indicators. It is structured around three dimensions: Basic Human Needs, Foundations of Well-being, and Opportunity. Scored on a 0–100 scale, with higher values indicating stronger social progress, the SPI is widely used to gauge sustainable development by capturing aspects of social and environmental health that GDP alone does not reflect.
Follow the full news here: Unpacking the Interrelationships between the Global Digitalization Index and Human Development